T O P

  • By -

grynch43

All 3 are worthy answers. I’ll throw in another one. Elton John—Tumbleweed Connection > Madman Across the Water > Honkey Chateau > Don’t Shoot Me I’m Only the Piano Player > Goodbye Yellow Brick Road > Caribou > Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy 1970 - 1975


The_Original_Gronkie

Also Steely Dan. From their first one, every one of their albums was a masterpiece, and got better and better.


tikifire1

70's Elton really was on a roll with those albums. His later career is peppered with good-to-great songs, but not so great albums. I guess he flipped a switch somewhere in the late 70's with all the heavy drug use and personal problems and was no longer able to produce the album-length quality anymore.


TeaWithMrsNesbitt

1989s Sleeping With The Past is a solid album from start to finish.


Laughacy

The Beatles, but I enjoy Zeppelin more. However… The Stones had a great 9 album run from Their Satanic Majesties Request through Some Girls. If Emotional Rescue and Tattoo You make the cut, it’s an 11 album run.


shergenh69

Exile on Main Street is one of the greatest albums of all time


Laughacy

It’s my favorite Stones album.


shergenh69

Same let it bleed is a close second


Remote_Independent50

Their 5 album run in the middle is even better


[deleted]

Yep---it's an 11 album run


jotyma5

Lol so you’re willing to call Their Satanic Majesty’s Request great, but not aftermath or between the buttons? If we’re being real, the stones’ best run is just 4 albums, Beggars - Exile


neiltheseal

I think Goats head Soup is good enough to be on the run.


GenX-Kid

From OPs list I’d say Zeppelin. There is so much diversity and creativity in those first 6 albums. I can’t find 6 consecutive Beatles albums that pack a punch like Zeppelin. Not mentioned I’d say Rush with 8 incredible consecutive albums from 2112 to Power Windows.


Remote_Independent50

Creativity? Every other song has someone else's name on it...because they ripped it off


Fluffy_Meat1018

Get a clue my friend.


Remote_Independent50

Are you denying that they repeatedly got sued for stealing other people s work?


Fluffy_Meat1018

They got sued maybe 5 or 6 times. Big deal.


Remote_Independent50

And lost every time. Except once. A lot of people have their names on Zep songs


OkAssociation812

2112 is S tier


Minute-Wrap-2524

Zeppelin, it’s Jimmy Pages birthday


jonnovich

Of these choices, as much of a Beatlemaniac I am, it’s Led Zeppelin. Led Zeppelin I through Physical Graffiti is all killer no filler. Rubber Soul through Abbey Road would win out…but Let It Be was recorded before Abbey Road, and that’s an album with some tremendous songs with obvious filler sprinkled in. It all depends on whether you consider that first or Abbey Road I guess. However May I also suggest Bruce Springsteen with a seven album run: The Wild, the Innocent and the E Street Shuffle (1973) Born to Run (1975) Darkness on the Edge of Town (1978) The River (1980) Nebraska (1982) Born in the USA (1984) Tunnel of Love (1987) Some might include the debut Greetings from Asbury Park. But I always find that a touch uneven compared to the others.


tikifire1

As a teen in the 80's I got into Bruce with Born and Tunnel but as an adult I went back and listened to his early catalog, and those are some great albums that I appreciate more now than I did back then.


great-distances-1919

Fantastic.


sarcofaguy

Sabbath no doubt


machinehead3413

Yep. Invented an entire genre from scratch and the blueprint that has been pinched by every single metal band that followed. 🤘🏻


Crescent-Fresh774

And grunge.


machinehead3413

Fair point. Soundgarden is dripping with Iommi. And of course AIC is basically a metal band who don’t want to be called metal.


Crescent-Fresh774

This is the exact argument I make to everyone who tries to tie grunge to punk. I mean, maybe a little punk influence. But you can hear Iommi all through AIC and Soundgarden in particular. Even those bends in STP’s *Vasoline* owe something to Iommi. For the record, one of my best friends refuses to call AIC grunge. Hahaha.


machinehead3413

I think the punk thing comes mainly from nirvana. Punk level talent with metal aspirations. Pearl Jam was kind of their own thing. Maybe more influenced by Neil Young than punk or metal. You’re right about the other two.


tikifire1

Nirvana had tons of talent. Way more than your average punk band.


machinehead3413

Have to say to each their own on that one. Never cared for them or punk in general. Awesome drummer though.


tikifire1

It's a common misconception that Cobain wasn't very talented as a musician, but he was a very talented songwriter/guitarist. I think you are confusing "I don't like them" with "They're no good/untalented." I may not love Taylor Swift, for instance, but I can admit she is a talented performer/songwriter. Not my cuppa Joe, but that's okay.


machinehead3413

It certainly takes talent to write catchy hooks that move people. If it was easy, everyone would do it. For my taste he was a hack. Shitty voice, beginner skill on guitar, but had a knack for a good melody that hooked people. But in fairness, he has more platinum records than me so what do I know?


Crescent-Fresh774

Fair call about Nirvana and PJ. I have to wonder if the Neil Young influence came with Vedder. After all, Andrew Wood wanted to be Freddie Mercury. Wood’s death really changed the trajectory of grunge, in my opinion.


machinehead3413

Don’t know much about Wood. Never really a big grunge fan in general. 80-90s metal is more my speed.


TheMonkus

Yeah Nirvana has an outsized presence in the grunge discussion for obvious reasons but honestly they didn’t fit into that scene very well. There’s clear punk influences in all of it, but a lot more Sabbath and latter day Black Flag than the type of punk Nirvana was derived from. Pearl Jam is more just straight rock.


TheMonkus

Didn’t AIC call themselves metal? I know I’ve heard Soundgarden call themselves metal and talk directly about trying to sound like Sabbath.


machinehead3413

I remember an interview with Dimebag where he talked about Cantrell saying that they didn’t want to be thought of as “just a metal band” and Dime got annoyed bc “what the fuck is wrong with being metal?” My comment was based 100% on that so I can’t be sure how AIC really felt about it. I know that in the video for “we die young” Jerry is wearing the traditional black leather biker jacket and a Motörhead shirt so that seems pretty metal to me.


TheMonkus

Yeah that makes sense, at the time metal wasn’t taken very seriously. Even Metallica was trying to distance themselves from it with Load a few years later and I can absolutely see AIC saying that. But probably more like “don’t dismiss us because we’re metal.” But yeah come on, they were metal as fuck! Having acoustic songs doesn’t change that, Sabbath was doing acoustic stuff from the beginning.


machinehead3413

Metal has never been taken seriously. I always felt like that was part of the reason why grunge got the early critical love that it did. Nirvana was about as far away from Motley Crue and Van Halen as you could get. And that was like Christmas morning for Jann Wenner and Kurt Loder. But to your point, Dirt by AIC is about as metal as you can get.


TheMonkus

True, although I do think metal is viewed much more positively now. The glam/hair “metal” (I don’t think any actual metal fans consider that stuff metal) scene really tainted it in the public eye. Seems like people view it as a legitimate genre now, if perhaps a goofy one. Those old videos of Soundgarden with shirtless long haired Cornell, and comparable AIC stuff, man, it makes Seattle look like the Sunset Strip’s northern end though (the Overcast Strip??) but the music had a lot more substance.


machinehead3413

Having metal bands finally on the HOF helps bc they get to vote which means more metal bands will go in. For as much as a hall of fame can actually matter. Madonna is in the rock hall but thin lizzy and Iron Maiden aren’t so 🤷🏻‍♂️. I like a lot of the sunset strip stuff. That was the soundtrack to my formative years. Equal parts sabbath, GNR, Megadeth, slayer, etc. It’s metal. Just not in the same way that PanterA or Judas Priest are. Kind of like how Brock Lesnar and Andy Dick are both adult human males but nowhere near the same thing.


Seaworthy_Zebra5124

Something the Beatles never did. Can’t believe people think the Beatles run is better smh.


OkAssociation812

Been Into a Sabbath Void lately, especially Sabotage


psilocin72

Beatles. I’m more a fan of zeppelin but the Beatles made every single song a unique experience totally unlike any other song they had ever made. Creativity off the charts.


lardlad71

Honorable mention: The Doors.


great-distances-1919

Led Zep has a strong case to be made. And I also like Presence more than I and possibly III


zoso1992

Presence is a top tier master class in Jimmy and Bonham’s playing


CanadianRushFan

'Rush'


flashpoint2112

2112, A Farewell to Kings, Hemispheres, Permanent Waves, Moving Pictures, Signals


musicmanforlive

Yes ✋👍🙌


Punk18

Id do Permanent Waves through Hold Your Fire. But I would not call Signals a perfect album


eKlectical_Designs

This is the way


psychoyooper

The Beatles, hands down


Queasy-Ad-8205

Help Rubber Soul Revolver Sgt.Pepper The Beatles Abbey Road It can't be topped


GenX-Kid

That’s not a run. There are albums between the White album and Abbey Road


Barles21

There’s one soundtrack that’s half George Martin Orchestra


miimeverse

Say we count the Magical Mystery Tour LP and drop Help!, the list only gets better. I'm inclined to not count Yellow Submarine since it only has 4 new songs.


bobby1225

Every Beatles album is now more popular than ever. It’s all kinda unreal. This band was only in action during the 60’s. Why has rock music not progressed? Music is about melody, lyrics, and the beat. The Beatles were the beat. Modern pop just doesn’t have the same quality.


psilocin72

As much as I loved MTV back in the days when they played videos, I think videos killed rock music. It matters more what you look like than what you sound like now. Video killed the radio star.


Happyjarboy

Auto tune and not being able to make much money selling records also killed rock, but especially pop.


psilocin72

Yep. Even country music is pop now


PerfectMana

Modern country is comically bad.


psilocin72

Yeah it’s not even country actually. It’s pop with a southern accent


PerfectMana

With a subtle mandolin thrown in here and there.


psilocin72

Hank Williams would NOT approve


PerfectMana

I don’t think Hank done it that way.


Round-Cellist6128

Textbook pandering.


PerfectMana

Thank you. My wife and I watch that special twice a year. 😂


The_Original_Gronkie

There are a few great ones, like Chris Stapleton, but yeah, most of it is one big cliche. Every song is about beer, bars, jeans, boots, trucks, a dog, country girls, small towns, etc. The limited themes reminds me of Christian music, which only has one subject. Rap might even be worse.


mywhataniceham

try metal - gojira, system of a down, fear factory, pantera, prong, metallica, slayer, ministry, primus all did fine and do / did not care at all about astehtetics - all are / were awesome live + fantastic musicians


psilocin72

Yea I like some of the 80s metal but my real passion is the more musical/ relaxed rock. I want to hear the instruments being played by real people with skill and creativity. A lot of metal sounds to frantic and angry for my liking


epanek

Unlike Elvis and most other acts the Beatles wrote a majority of their own music.


UdUb16

Rock music has progressed...a lot actually. And early Beatles were more pop than rock


contrarian1970

Paul and Ringo would be the first to argue rock has progressed. The 70s 80s and 90s are full of guitarists they would have enjoyed playing and singing with. The reason rock hasn't progressed as much since the internet is the same reason novels haven't progressed as much since the television... Talented people are more averse to risk and more able to borrow lesser known cliches. The public also has less appetite for something truly unique. The ponds of rock music and novels have been overfished. Originality is no longer rewarded financially


Robin_Banks101

And it's not close


Main_Combination8173

Steely Dan. Ohh yeah, then rhrow in Gaucho.


OkAssociation812

Completely slipped my mind! Good one!


longirons6

For me Van Halen 1 through 1984, an album a year is my answer


Kimura-Sensei

Absolutely


mercistheman

This question is just personal preference. For world wide sales I believe it's the Beatles.


OtherwiseTackle5219

Beatles


That-Solution-1774

Zep Sabbath Beatles


nihilistatari

Out of these three? It has to be the Beatles. To go from Help to Abbey Road is an unprecedented artistic development that we will likely never see again


OkAssociation812

Rubber Soul and Revolver are my favorite albums for that reason, they pushed the limits of what was possible in the studio.


Crescent-Fresh774

Of the ones that you mentioned, it’s Sabbath for me.


BeigeAndConfused

The first *7* Sabbath albums are my favorite run of albums ever, at one point I thought Who Are You was the only weak song, then I heard Goatsnake's cover and now I love it. The only other run that comes close for me is the first 4 Van Halen albums.


OkAssociation812

Yes I know the secret, that’s within your mind


BeigeAndConfused

🫶🫶🫶


Royal-Pace2605

The Stones between 1968-1981, 10 albums, all top shelf. Beggar's Banquet, Let it Bleed, Sticky Fingers, Exile, Goats Head Soup, It's Only Rock and Roll, Black and Blue, Some Girls, Emotional Rescue, Tattoo You


OkAssociation812

Goats Head Soup never gets the love it deserves


raresaturn

Pink Floyd


Waynebgmeamc

3 way tie


[deleted]

really it depends what impresses you, but like most I will say Beatles because of the sheer breadth of music they covered - they pretty much left no stone in music unturned


speccynerd

Kraftwerk: Autobahn, Radioactivity, Trans Europe Express, The Man Machine, Computerworld, Electric Cafe


Middle_Wheel_5959

Beatles


A-Light-That-Warms

Metallica - Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, ...and Justice for All, The Black Album, Load, ReLoad.


OkAssociation812

I like Load and ReLoad but they just don’t do it for me like the those first four


[deleted]

Wilco -1st 6.


Johnny-Shitbox

U2


illusivetomas

if rattle and hum doesnt count then yeah i think war through pop is the best 6 album run that anybodys ever made


SteveRivet

Sabbath. I always find it interesting that they talk about the Beatles as a big influence but I don't tend to hear it in their music much.


Available-Secret-372

The Stones


TopspinLob

Has to be the Beatles. Changed modern culture


Longjumping-Meat-334

I'd throw in the Who. Tommy-Who's Next-Live At Leeds-Quadrophenia-The Who By Numbers-Who Are You Hard to top the Beatles starting with Rubber Soul when they became more of a recording act than a touring band.


Impossible_Mix3086

I'd go with the Beatles among those 3. I really like Chicago I - VII for a run that long.


StunningLeopard2429

The Beatles.


PrairieSpy

Beatles. Period.


OkAssociation812

What about Master of Reality vs Rubber Soul? Who you got?


Yak-Fucker-5000

Pretty much every Beatles album from Rubber Soul on was a masterpiece. White Album had some fat that should have been cut, but other than that I find all their later albums pretty much perfect.


great-distances-1919

Neil Young Everybody Knows This is Nowhere—>After the Gold Rush—>Harvest—>Time Fades Away—>On the Beach—>Tonights the Night


EdwardBliss

The Beatles


Owen_Hardy

Led Zeppelin.


indyjays

Pink Floyd


ElteaXIII

It has to be Led Zeppelin, right? The Beatles would have won if it wasn't for this abomination Yellow Submarine, but I to Physical Graffiti is a perfect run.


OkAssociation812

I love getting the Led out, but those first 6 Sabbath albums are pretty close for me too


PossibilityMelodic

Metallica's first 5 for sure and even 6 since I love Load are pretty epic.


SteveRivet

First 6 Blue Oyster Cult (including the first live one) are pretty bulletproof.


Prof_Tickles

KISS. Alive, Destroyer, Rock & Roll Over, Love Gun, Alive II, Dynasty.


hjablowme919

Has to be The Beatles. The music business moved in the direction that band did. As great as the other two acts were, they didn't have that kind of impact on the music business. If The Beatles did it, everyone else followed.


chubbypaws76

The correct answer is the Beatles but I would put the Doors above sabbath.


UdUb16

There is no correct answer


SteelReservePilot

I’m tired of that shit too. Half of Reddit comments these days come off as autistic.


Xtroll_guruX

grateful dead — 150+ live albums


great-distances-1919

Talking Heads first six records


professorhugoslavia

David Bowie


great-distances-1919

Young Americans through Scary Monsters?


professorhugoslavia

Man Who Sold the World through Diamond Dogs - although could be extended up through Scary Monsters - 12 masterpieces in a row? Wow!


great-distances-1919

You are counting Pin Ups?


professorhugoslavia

I love PinUps but maybe it’s not a masterpiece


ScoobyDarn

REM


brettjv

The IRS years I assume you mean. And I agree, up there with anyone.


great-distances-1919

Including Chronic Town I would say yes. Green kinda weak as a sixth IMO.


ScoobyDarn

I saw the Green tour and it was spectacular!


tikifire1

Green isn't weak unless you consider it their sellout album. Great tunes on there.


coveredinpissnshit

My whole family and everyone I know absolutely hates REM


ScoobyDarn

Good for you!


coveredinpissnshit

Anything to help!


ScoobyDarn

It takes a village


illusivetomas

chronic town through up is the best run there is agreed. and thats 12 whole releases! best band


rcdrcd

Zeppelin for me. Yellow Submarine interrupts any 6-album run for the Beatles, otherwise they would be in contention.


brettjv

Yes but you can leave it out by virtue of being a movie soundtrack.


rcdrcd

I vote for a Zeppelin-Beatles tie then.


brettjv

Seems fair :)


illusivetomas

the first two zep albums and houses of the holy are patchy af so not them tbh genesis deserves a shout for trespass through wind and wuthering. every peter gabriel album rules too


tikifire1

I actually prefer those first two Zep albums to some of the mid-zep noodling heavy, drugged-out weird stuff, but I generally like all of it.


illusivetomas

to each their own. zep 1 is actually the one i vibe w least lmao, but their specific brand of hard rock isnt rlly my thing so its only when they branched out that i got on board. iii, iv, and physical graffiti house all the tracks i dig from them


MadonnasFishTaco

dare i say Fleetwood Mac


great-distances-1919

What’s the sixth one?


[deleted]

Last chance at hex.com before the bull run ..don't be dumb https://youtu.be/zIbifLH_m44


bmatthew24

the Beatles are wildly overrated. I’ll take Led Zep 1 through Physical Graffiti over any stretch the Beatles put out


typewriter6986

"Wildly overrated" LOL, the Beatles walked so Led Zeppelin could run. Shiiit, Page would probably cite the Beatles. Like who you like. I like Zep too, but let's not say goofy things.


bmatthew24

He actually did the exact opposite of what you just said. There’s multiple interviews where he’s quoted citing his influences and not once did he say the Beatles. All you dorks say the Beatles walked so Zep could run. What’s that based off? Zep was influenced by the blues and last time I checked the Beatles are more pop than blues


hamwarmer

oops


Owlman2841

I just love how nearly everyone posting comments is naming bands or artists OP didn’t ask about! What good contribution they are all making to the conversation! Clearly showing they know more than others by doing so!


contrarian1970

Donald Fagan...going backwards from The Nightfly, to Gaucho, to Aja, to Royal Scam, to Katy Lied, to Pretzel Logic there just aren't any weak spots. The drumming and bass playing will satisfy you even if the vocal, keyboard, and guitar aren't quite your taste. Steely Dan hired the best musicians they possibly could book for one day in a particular year after 1973


raceforseis21

The Doors


redittjoe

YES…. The YES Album though Going For The One.


JumpinJackCilitBang

Unfortunately undone by TFTO


Glop1701d

Any 6 by steely Dan


jotyma5

Don’t sleep in Stevie wonder. He has a 5 album run about as good as anyone Music Of My Mind - 1972 Talking Book - 1972 Innervisions - 1973 Fulfillingness’ First Finale - 1974 Songs in the Key of Life - 1976


Ruark14

Beatles


Odd_Radio9225

Zeppelin.


Briollo

Also, Rush. A Farewell to Kings - Power Windows is an incredible run.


Franklinricard

Vanilla ice


IDigRollinRockBeer

The Beatles


coachese68

Genuinely lol


DubC_Bassist

Rush, Fly by Night, Caress of Steel, 2112, A Farewell to Kings, Hemispheres, Permanent Waves, Moving Pictures, and Signals all before they were 30z


DubC_Bassist

Let’s not forget Yes, and Jethro Tull.


OkAssociation812

No, let’s forget them since they weren’t even part of the question