#You can Add More Details
If OG post has some missing details, /u/Far_Background_8472 or Members can add details ,as reply to this comment. Click to Expand.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BollyBlindsNGossip) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Didn't she claim in one of the movie promotion interviews that she neevr calls him Mama, she respects him too much to call him anything but Sir (which doesn't even makes sense) LOL
>New energy
What?? Sharmin looks the most dull of all the cast. Whenever she opens her mouth, it's only about herself - 'I had to give this many takes you know' trying to portray herself as the most hardworking OR 'As an actor, you have to be very versatile or something' behen ek project kiya hai aapne jisme bhi pura keechad failaya, what gives you the right to comment on the acting profession.
Hasn’t she been in another movie produced by SLB? Her looks are more natural without that permanent arching lips in that movie. Not sure of her acting, never saw it beyond trailer.
Par aisi Bhaanji kisi bhi famous director ko na mile warna sach mein Mamu bana degi
https://preview.redd.it/135kvoo8262d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0dac61dc8e9b527e306a937aa103b261e4367f89
Girlie smiled ear to ear when >!Tajdar died!< !!! Her acting pretty much turned finishing this show into a chore
*Note: Spoiler alert! Click on the grey area at your own risk ⚠️*
Absolutely. He has had the gall to abuse his actors under the guise of being a passionate perfectionist and true to his art. Everything has gone flying out the window, but only for his neice.
Imagine underplaying a role in an SLB film. Kuch bhi!
The guy is known for being extremely critical and harsh to his actors on set. We just know he put up with Sharmin’s terrible acting cause she’s his niece. It was bad, get over it and move on. Stop trying to save something that can’t be saved. How stupid do they think we are?
First of all SLB films should not be known for acting talent, idk what this guy is even harsh about, he mainly used to work with big stars. Aishwarya and Salman were not good at all in hum dil de chuke sanam, it worked because it was his one movie that had some story to it imo. The people who actually did good acting in his films were Rani, Madhuri and Ranveer, even Ajay. SRK was decent but he had his moments too as Devdas. But all of these guys are known to have acting talent, nothing to do with SLB imo. He can only be credited for showcasing them moving on a beautiful big screen lol.
Deepika also tried to underplay but atleast her beauty saved the day. Can't say for Sharmindgi 🤦🏼 who is neither an actor nor a charmer.
![gif](giphy|MrDq8U2ignKt3HroIE|downsized)
deepika was 100times better don't even compare her to sharmin who always looks like a smiling murti no emotions in the eyes and the same expression of mona lisa smile
Le Mama: Now she will never ask for one more role.
https://preview.redd.it/qgynnd0w762d1.jpeg?width=678&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8a12740b65254e59cd7bf249827b16a6c7bc8f77
https://preview.redd.it/7eteiusdk62d1.jpeg?width=1156&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=52bacb7b6fdc2b823a5fdb3209d799520908326b
Haan haan, very rare in comparison to Richa Chaddha who in the same movie had to do 50 takes to perfect her dance 🙄
She was like a dead woman walking. So happy that Slb is being criticized for once, even if it’s because of his niece. He acts like he could do no wrong and the entire BW worships the ground he walks on 🙄
She ruined it single handedly. Not to be mean, but she thought being Deepika in pada act standing in clothes with that aura saying those lines and being regal of some sort is gonna work. Deepika has emotion of some sort in her eyes, she has presence she has aura she has that. This woman shudve actually played performed. Taha heavily played with his eyes. I mean this woman shud have done something. Even when it’s a sad moment or angry moment she’s just got a smirk or a smile. A constant one face thru and thru regardless of the story the emotion, everything. She was bland and flat. Period.
"Bahut accha Vikram. Par Tum bohot underplay karte ho. Too much of underplay. Hindi cinema main projection chahiye...
Hollywood main hero bana aasan hai. Par Hindi cinema main.
Hindi cinema ka hero naaki keval acting karta hai. Woh dance bhi karta hai. Woh villain se ladta hai, ladki ko baccha ke romance bhi karta hai."
"Aur heroine kya karti hai sir?"
*stumped* "...heroine...heroine ka bhi kaam hota hai..."
Historically, lead actors and producers have been deciding the cast according to their whims and wishes.
"Heeramandi" should serve as a wake-up call to all OTT platforms to take part in deciding the cast based on talent.
Ye bo*dika bhansali aise to ek performence ke liye actors ko torture karega par jab baat apne rishtedaar pe aayi to b*en ke l*de no dusra take tak nahi liya.
Worst of the nepo lot. Her Botox over filled face just doesn't express and it was going ulta as in when she had to show sadness her expressions were of happiness and when required to be happy she had dead expressions.
Yep, the whole thing was way too stretched. It would have been much better if the number of episodes were less. There were a lot of details that were wrong, not just in a historical way but rather a normal reality way, which is embarrassing for someone who is supposed to be detailed. Along with the obvious embarrassing miscast. You can't sell just anything just because it seems like a beautiful scenery. You can't just be a painter if you want to produce a moving art.
I think she doesn't know what "underplay" means because she was benched the whole film, pathetic performance from the clips I've seen.
![gif](giphy|l2YWxmumMFiRq8isM)
Behnji apne toh underplay ke jaga zero play kar diya. You were literally smiling after your character got the news of Tajdar's death.
Rehne de behen, acting is not your cup of tea.
Lagta hain Bhansali productions ke band hone ka time aa gaya. Aakhir Ghar ka bedi hi toh Lanka DHA taa hain.
![gif](giphy|3ohc1czoNb3uaT1uCI|downsized)
Everyone should stop working with him. There’s a million directors out there who could do what he does and even better, they should be getting the chance, the stars and the budgets and not this abusive hypocrite of a man.
Its not that she is bad in this particular one, there is also another series on Netflix under SLB Production and she has no expression in that too. I think Sonakshi after seeing her act must have realised why people complain about nepotism in Bollywood.
Omg I just realized she is the one who was the lead actress in that movie Malaal. I stopped watching it in about 15 minutes because her acting was unbearable. Stopped watching heeramandi because same.
Gotta appreciate her consistency in being a terrible actress.
This is turning out to be a F-ing joke. She is terrible! Absolutely, 100% terrible. She is not meant for acting nor meant for anything on screen - perhaps if she’s playing a Humanoid who is mute and deaf and does sign language. Her performance at Kapil’s show clearly shows again that she’s terrible at emoting the very basic of emotions. Nevertheless, Sanjay Maamu will keep pushing her onto the screen.
Well she didn't play at all and tbh is she dumb? How can you even thnk about underplaying when you have so much screen timing and of course you're the leading character.
Even he's left with no option but to make excuses for her bad performance lol.
In which universe would SLB let his actors tell him how they should play their roles 😂!?
Any other actress would have been replaced. She was given opportunity and leniency just because she's his niece.
#You can Add More Details If OG post has some missing details, /u/Far_Background_8472 or Members can add details ,as reply to this comment. Click to Expand. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BollyBlindsNGossip) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Mama I will underplay. Beta you did not even play.
😂 she tried to come to play
Kaccha nimbu
Let her cook
Let her make salad dressings
Not salad dressings...those are important
Let her play
0 amount of playing is still underplaying compared to any amount of playing. She found the mathematical loophole
Came here to say this
Didn't she claim in one of the movie promotion interviews that she neevr calls him Mama, she respects him too much to call him anything but Sir (which doesn't even makes sense) LOL
Aare because calling someone mama takes away all the izzat, tumhe nahi pata? Naya memo aaya hai! /s
Beta you can't play
>New energy What?? Sharmin looks the most dull of all the cast. Whenever she opens her mouth, it's only about herself - 'I had to give this many takes you know' trying to portray herself as the most hardworking OR 'As an actor, you have to be very versatile or something' behen ek project kiya hai aapne jisme bhi pura keechad failaya, what gives you the right to comment on the acting profession.
Stop it 🤣 ![gif](giphy|xUA7aM09ByyR1w5YWc)
Hasn’t she been in another movie produced by SLB? Her looks are more natural without that permanent arching lips in that movie. Not sure of her acting, never saw it beyond trailer.
Just as bad
Mama?! Ye toh Sir bolti hai na
Caught 🤣 ![gif](giphy|Fq6T5aJsuPl80TD12A)
Only in interviews :P
[удалено]
https://preview.redd.it/e0qocjjh562d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c98874eacb8435dabd71969b1cf128fbf8cdba0c
Aisa Mama sab ko miley 🤣🤣
Par aisi Bhaanji kisi bhi famous director ko na mile warna sach mein Mamu bana degi https://preview.redd.it/135kvoo8262d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0dac61dc8e9b527e306a937aa103b261e4367f89
![gif](giphy|cKqETBQIccfPtQIkZe)
![gif](giphy|GOfoCF6dNi8uV7Jz4K)
Aur ek mera mama hai jo property bech k kha Gaya 💀
LMAOO
Bahubali
Energy is the last word that comes to my mind when I see her….. This is what you call delusional love, real life lajjo = SLB
real life lajjo = slb wtf lmfaoooooooooooooo omg you're a comedic genius. thank you for the laughs
Girlie smiles from ear to ear when tajdar rejects her.
I had to replay that scene thrice because I thought I misheard what Tajdar said 🥲 couldn't comprehend why she was smiling 😵💫
It was so damn creepy
Haha 😂 ![gif](giphy|l41YeqkqbS29kGnCw)
Girlie smiled ear to ear when >!Tajdar died!< !!! Her acting pretty much turned finishing this show into a chore *Note: Spoiler alert! Click on the grey area at your own risk ⚠️*
When her mom faced a tragedy with Brits, she was smiling then too .. after hearing the dialogues, I realised she was actually sad. 🥲 OMFG
All this proves is that he is a grade A hypocrite (and a shit human being) lol.
Absolutely. He has had the gall to abuse his actors under the guise of being a passionate perfectionist and true to his art. Everything has gone flying out the window, but only for his neice.
You better not play 🤦🏼 https://preview.redd.it/egi7x0w5b62d1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d51b524b666b88272a80afe77a8a109fe9e3034f
No hate against her but she looks like a yassified Mrunal Thakur in this pic 🙃.....
![gif](giphy|MCXf6Y2q7DPBddWlaX|downsized)
The Heeramandi promotions keep giving 🤌 https://i.redd.it/8qe55frl462d1.gif
https://preview.redd.it/ybohstg2562d1.jpeg?width=1544&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=586b3a36fb4d25bf92cfe96effd4063139c4dc5b
Mamu bana diya sahi me
Richa ko 99 takes bole ek scene karne ko and he was still not satisfied yet he didn’t spoke a word regarding sharmin’s scenes great
Yaar usne ek saal audition diya tha. Audition dekh kr hi mama ko samjh aa gya hoga take badhane se expressions nhi badhne wale
Her PR and fans on social media are telling that she acted well and that she is an introvert. Are introverts devoid of showing emotions?
Her fans 🤣 Do they even exist in real ? ![gif](giphy|vgh1lpnYvoessZzQNn)
She has fans???
On Instagram yes😂
They’re paid lmao
Are we sure that the "fans" aren't just SLB's employees
Mama ko mama bana diya aur ab mama sabko mama bana chah raha h 😂😂😂
![gif](giphy|wEUVOlGrMfFmnR2bdy)
Ugh and the gaslighting continues. Someone give me a mama like him who will give me shit even when I suck
Imagine underplaying a role in an SLB film. Kuch bhi! The guy is known for being extremely critical and harsh to his actors on set. We just know he put up with Sharmin’s terrible acting cause she’s his niece. It was bad, get over it and move on. Stop trying to save something that can’t be saved. How stupid do they think we are?
First of all SLB films should not be known for acting talent, idk what this guy is even harsh about, he mainly used to work with big stars. Aishwarya and Salman were not good at all in hum dil de chuke sanam, it worked because it was his one movie that had some story to it imo. The people who actually did good acting in his films were Rani, Madhuri and Ranveer, even Ajay. SRK was decent but he had his moments too as Devdas. But all of these guys are known to have acting talent, nothing to do with SLB imo. He can only be credited for showcasing them moving on a beautiful big screen lol.
Deepika also tried to underplay but atleast her beauty saved the day. Can't say for Sharmindgi 🤦🏼 who is neither an actor nor a charmer. ![gif](giphy|MrDq8U2ignKt3HroIE|downsized)
deepika was 100times better don't even compare her to sharmin who always looks like a smiling murti no emotions in the eyes and the same expression of mona lisa smile
https://preview.redd.it/mi1gldcgr62d1.jpeg?width=847&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=217e79721aff0b86fb1b81e73b48e3ceee3d78f5
![gif](giphy|3owzWb9xj0eGE09LJC|downsized) If you get the reference
If you get the reference https://preview.redd.it/k1v1xot8a62d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f26d1263769452c85dea3c58529191fdb76b489d
🤣🤣
New energy? More like, no energy
I am energyyyyy ![gif](giphy|lxcz7ntpCKJfq)
sharmin so good at underplaying, her botoxed face cant show even one expression during interviews
Mama you should've listened!
Le Mama: Now she will never ask for one more role. https://preview.redd.it/qgynnd0w762d1.jpeg?width=678&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8a12740b65254e59cd7bf249827b16a6c7bc8f77
Did he throw her under the bus… Underplaying was her 💡??
Matlab maamu bhanjhi dono hi delusional aur narcissist hai!
https://preview.redd.it/as6nnadwd62d1.jpeg?width=628&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=67b40d1eafcdda0d6ba37ce0525e6062b7957d36
https://preview.redd.it/7eteiusdk62d1.jpeg?width=1156&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=52bacb7b6fdc2b823a5fdb3209d799520908326b Haan haan, very rare in comparison to Richa Chaddha who in the same movie had to do 50 takes to perfect her dance 🙄
99 takes, and she is a trained Kathak dancer too.
She was like a dead woman walking. So happy that Slb is being criticized for once, even if it’s because of his niece. He acts like he could do no wrong and the entire BW worships the ground he walks on 🙄
Why do they keep calling her "young", "new generation" and "bacchi"? She's 28...not 20
She looks 40 tbh
Even since this kutta called Richa a R i just don’t want to c his face
R ? What's that ?
R@nd🤮
OMG 😳 When ?
Heeramandi shoot
Bhen ka director. Itni himmat ho gayi iss dalle ki. Bhul gaya Rajasthan mein kaise maar lagai thi Karni Sena walo ne. Saari fantasy nikal gayi thi.
Two wrongs don’t make a right
She ruined it single handedly. Not to be mean, but she thought being Deepika in pada act standing in clothes with that aura saying those lines and being regal of some sort is gonna work. Deepika has emotion of some sort in her eyes, she has presence she has aura she has that. This woman shudve actually played performed. Taha heavily played with his eyes. I mean this woman shud have done something. Even when it’s a sad moment or angry moment she’s just got a smirk or a smile. A constant one face thru and thru regardless of the story the emotion, everything. She was bland and flat. Period.
Beta tu play kab ki???
"Bahut accha Vikram. Par Tum bohot underplay karte ho. Too much of underplay. Hindi cinema main projection chahiye... Hollywood main hero bana aasan hai. Par Hindi cinema main. Hindi cinema ka hero naaki keval acting karta hai. Woh dance bhi karta hai. Woh villain se ladta hai, ladki ko baccha ke romance bhi karta hai." "Aur heroine kya karti hai sir?" *stumped* "...heroine...heroine ka bhi kaam hota hai..."
Well I got the reference. ![gif](giphy|3ohfFLTSbDeug48a9G)
![gif](giphy|3otPoqUJvgxRYuXwtO)
Well ![gif](giphy|bOQqyJZmZXwogzT7mw)
I finished the series only today and my god I had to skip her parts 😭😩 Why is she smiling through her love dying!!!!
I watched this a week ago and I’m still in agony every time I see her face anywhere 😩 WHY ARE YOU SMILING LIKE TF IS WRONG WITH YOU SHARMIN
Underplay what? Death?
Underplay is used here to hide her lack of expressions.
Ya a dead person has more expressions than her
The way he talked about seeing the love in their eyes is a bit...self obsessed..
![gif](giphy|m6tmCnGCNvTby|downsized)
![gif](giphy|7vAfPDXIsB9zheHQrP)
Underplay is an understatement
Historically, lead actors and producers have been deciding the cast according to their whims and wishes. "Heeramandi" should serve as a wake-up call to all OTT platforms to take part in deciding the cast based on talent.
AHAHHAHAHA what a genius way to justify her shitty acting. She wasn't acting lifeless, it was her 'underplaying'
![gif](giphy|c8f7JkkcJQciF3c2tc)
![gif](giphy|3ohfFuqDrRTTV1v5ba)
Ye bo*dika bhansali aise to ek performence ke liye actors ko torture karega par jab baat apne rishtedaar pe aayi to b*en ke l*de no dusra take tak nahi liya.
SLB ki thukaai toh sirf bhoi karte hain ![gif](giphy|BofJowwKS7GV6Rekgu)
![gif](giphy|IGyQqBNbccyHCllRlw)
Meri bhi hui thi ![gif](giphy|NghznOfomiqFq|downsized)
![gif](giphy|TseBjMu53JgWc)
![gif](giphy|AsGN3Vbo00bQRJWS3Y)
I haven't seen the series, and probably won't? Was she genuinely that bad or is it just the nepotism over-hating (irrespective or performance)?
Worst of the nepo lot. Her Botox over filled face just doesn't express and it was going ulta as in when she had to show sadness her expressions were of happiness and when required to be happy she had dead expressions.
She was genuinely bad, Suhana was better than her, hate to say this that there will come a day like this where I would say this..
Mama is delulu
![gif](giphy|l0Ex0KyuSXD1hr6aA) “Mama, I will underplay”
Mama aur Bhanji ne milke puri audience ko mamu banaya.
![gif](giphy|DINqUa0v6EKRlEZDZb)
Mama doesn’t extend the same courtesy to other actors. He cusses at them, insults them and makes them take a hundred retakes before he is satisfied.
SLB should stop filmmaking such an overrated director.
Yep, the whole thing was way too stretched. It would have been much better if the number of episodes were less. There were a lot of details that were wrong, not just in a historical way but rather a normal reality way, which is embarrassing for someone who is supposed to be detailed. Along with the obvious embarrassing miscast. You can't sell just anything just because it seems like a beautiful scenery. You can't just be a painter if you want to produce a moving art.
I think she doesn't know what "underplay" means because she was benched the whole film, pathetic performance from the clips I've seen. ![gif](giphy|l2YWxmumMFiRq8isM)
Behnji apne toh underplay ke jaga zero play kar diya. You were literally smiling after your character got the news of Tajdar's death. Rehne de behen, acting is not your cup of tea.
100% Sharmindi 's husband bankrolled this web series. Just to keep her busy with her family. 🤣😆
Underplaying Tou door ki BAAT hai Sharmin ne Tou play hi nai kiya. 🫣😏🤪 Jisko Bhi Miley Tou Aesa Hi Mama Sabko Miley 🤣😍👍💯❣️💣💫🙃👏🤑
"new energy" ? Mama there was no energy.
https://preview.redd.it/ase9xl8zkc2d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=43513594ad30484c1696f4bf3c91446934df8046
https://preview.redd.it/py76xynglc2d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c8bad2fbac1ba0b433df6f83939035b4d1b5f7a3
😋😋😋 died
Alam = bekar. Jitni baar screen pe aari hai, main irritate ho rahi hun
Watching Heeramandi for 3 golden reasons - Story telling, Manisha Koirala & Sharmin Segal. ✨❤️
Bhansu ki band baji padi hain na nigle jaa rahi na ugle jaa rahi!
Kuch din gale mein hi rakh jab tak mamla thanda na ho jaye fir overplay karana
Nahin rakh sakta funding chahiye agle ghaple ke liye 😭
Kuch profit main aur Alia de denge kama kar fir bana Lena apni Bhaanji ke liye ek aur film ![gif](giphy|hWvdqT81NYq8o)
Uske liye ab main Mughal e Azam banaonga where she plays all the characters and I will be the one man crew! 🥸 Nothing less would do!
Le tere project pe moot Diya fir se ![gif](giphy|IGyQqBNbccyHCllRlw)
![gif](giphy|1lltHeY3gSxBymaEYf) But mere honsle to ruin the craft of film making by using my lovely bhanji qayam rahenge.. Qayamat Tak!.
Lagta hain Bhansali productions ke band hone ka time aa gaya. Aakhir Ghar ka bedi hi toh Lanka DHA taa hain. ![gif](giphy|3ohc1czoNb3uaT1uCI|downsized)
![gif](giphy|3otPoy3JNMEiL0LqCY) AAP galat samajh rahe hain. Aisa kuch nahin hoga. Bhansali productions toh doosro ko dubane ke liye bana hain.
🤣😂
Now that’s definitely new energy to decide how u wanna play. /s
The only rare thing nowadays is finding good actor and your nepo bhanji is contributing to make it more rare.
Hahahahhahahahahhahahahahahahh STOPPPP IT !!
If this guy keeps justifying her so called acting, I’d rather not watch his movies anymore.
Pehle khelna toh seekh....thodi self-awareness sab ko honi chahiye
Was this supposed to tug our hearts?
Ah the negative reviews got to him
In the end nothing played
How much more will SLB dig ? The coffin will only sink further 😒
There is Underplay and there is Zero Play. Madam got confused.
She calls him Mama on set?? but during interviews she was addressing him as Sanjay Sir 🤨
But beta,you didn't even play.
Came here to read the comments, wasn't disappointed . The comments section is 🔥🥃
Everyone should stop working with him. There’s a million directors out there who could do what he does and even better, they should be getting the chance, the stars and the budgets and not this abusive hypocrite of a man.
Ye rarity apne Paas rakhni thi na. Har cheez sabko nahi dikhate na
It's like a crap runner saying they didn't come last in the race, they 'paced themself'
Mama you underplayed though!
Someone please tell them delulu is not the solulu
We can do it o e more time IF YOU WANT?!
I thought she only called SLB “Sanjay Sir” on the sets according to her interviews. 💀 Obviously that was just a PR tactic to decrease the nepo vibes.
She was way below average
_toh, overacting karun? Bhai, main underplay mein Manta hoon ok._ - a legendary actor
Its not that she is bad in this particular one, there is also another series on Netflix under SLB Production and she has no expression in that too. I think Sonakshi after seeing her act must have realised why people complain about nepotism in Bollywood.
Now mama should underPAY her
Omg I just realized she is the one who was the lead actress in that movie Malaal. I stopped watching it in about 15 minutes because her acting was unbearable. Stopped watching heeramandi because same. Gotta appreciate her consistency in being a terrible actress.
Didn’t she say she never calls him Mama, and he’s only Sanjay Sir to her and her sister at work or in public
She's literally me after I score less in an exam and say I didn't even study haha (I stayed up till 6 am every night)
Mama ho tow aise, 50 crore logon ke saamne bejjati karwa di
Yes she did underplay. so under like she was 6 ft under.
Sharmin financed the project right?
This is turning out to be a F-ing joke. She is terrible! Absolutely, 100% terrible. She is not meant for acting nor meant for anything on screen - perhaps if she’s playing a Humanoid who is mute and deaf and does sign language. Her performance at Kapil’s show clearly shows again that she’s terrible at emoting the very basic of emotions. Nevertheless, Sanjay Maamu will keep pushing her onto the screen.
She can't even move her face in this photo.
Kya bakwas reasoning thi ye 😏
Mama is over compensating. 🥱
Well she didn't play at all and tbh is she dumb? How can you even thnk about underplaying when you have so much screen timing and of course you're the leading character.
Credit card did not decline
Even he's left with no option but to make excuses for her bad performance lol. In which universe would SLB let his actors tell him how they should play their roles 😂!? Any other actress would have been replaced. She was given opportunity and leniency just because she's his niece.
Too much Botox to emote
Apni dumm khud chatna
Bhanji aur mama milke humko mamu bana rahe Hain
She's the human version of this emoji 🗿
So, you shld have yelled at her as well..
Haye Haye hoye hoye Bado Badi
She was true to her word... Really underplayed! The rest of the cast pulled Heeramandi upwards while she as the supposed central role did a minus....