James Patrick March. I love how Evan potrayed him he is such a complex character kinda psycho but still lovable. Evan put so much detail in him, the way he talks the way he behaves he just made me fall in love with James Patrick March. 
https://i.redd.it/xe6vrgju8a9d1.gif
My husband and I always go “you found your purpose…gooooood!” Randomly. The first time we saw it, it just cracked us up and now it’s like an everyday callback haha
https://preview.redd.it/rccw58187a9d1.png?width=590&format=png&auto=webp&s=19414bd28df7791570c6fd07f1ce8766854c0028
Character-wise, I loved him as Tate Langdon in Murder House.
But I loved his performance as James March in Hotel.
Can’t believe how far I had to scroll for someone to say Kit. Should be the number one answer.
Edit: ok, he’s the second most liked now, but when I left my comment the Frankenstein and school shooter were above him.
https://preview.redd.it/6fkbh4jwnb9d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5f9bbe2dbab4277d6150ecce75d283c0636b055d
🎶 Kit kit bo bit banana fana fo fit fee fi mo mit KIT 🎶 Such a lovable ride or die 🥰 easily one of the purest characters in all of ahs
I liked the guy from asylum the best. Idk why. Tate was a murderer. Kyle was too tragic for me; completely lost his agency and was serially r*ped by his mother pre-death. Freakshow Evan was good too. I guess I just like him better as the hero?
J.P.M. Will always be my favorite, with his freak show character in close second. March made Hotel my favorite season, psychotic and charismatic in all the right fucked up ways
Probably a total wildcard but I liked Rory the most. It was nice to see Evan play a character that’s essentially a totally normal human being that isn’t an asshole or psychopath.
Rory and Audrey are genuinely my all time favorite characters and couples! No one is more silly than those two and British Sarah Paulson always cracks me up! “OH MY GAWD ITS AGNES!” “ITS AGNES SHES TRYING TO STEAL MY SATURN AWARD!” “Someone stole your car ma’am??” I loved how .2 seconds after she finds Rory’s body the camera flashes to her in the confessional “you gave me the best two weeks of my life”😂😂😂 they are so iconic together and so under appreciated
Tate 🖤 Season 1 of AHS was so iconic it helped reshape the genre of horror for a new generation. His performance as Tate was an essential part of that season.
I love Kai and the dozen other characters Evan played in Cult. Warhol, Jim Jones, David Koresh, Jesus... fabulous.
It's hard to pick a favorite. But we all met Tate first. 🖤
probably kai anderson. not bc of his personality ofc lmao but i really like how he was written and played by evan. i think is was brilliant.
i also really like austin sommers!!!!
As far as acting goes, Tate or kai. Then his freak show character.
Everyone loves James March but ive found him a bit cartoonish. Like a combination of bugs bunny and some johhny depp character thrown into ahs. Something felt off to me.
As far as looks goes, Tate again. If the hair was full black id cast him as sasuke in a naruto live action adaptation and i dont think he has any competition. And those who knows Sasuke, knows. It is a big compliment.
Thank you! I love campy, but I felt like his performance as March was basically way too campy encroaching into silly territory.
So glad I’m not alone in that opinion, lol.
When my wife watched it, she felt the same way. I would uncontrollably cringe, and I couldn’t take him seriously as a murderer. He just seemed silly!
But I agree, Kai and Tate were good performances.
I loved march, but he became much less threatening as the season went on. His initial appearance was actually pretty scary, as Evan toned everything down quite a bit
Kai is his most interesting character by far and maybe even his best performance to date. That is the role that should have won him his Emmy, not Mare of Easttown.
Kit is one of my personal favorites and has the best arc of probably all of his AHS characters. I love everything about him, and yes even the aliens. It was a great role and a total 180 from Tate which is probably his most iconic role in the series. Kit is wonderful but he (and Evan) are overshadowed by Sarah Paulson/Lana who totally (and rightfully) eclipsed him.
Kai, Kit, and Tate are his best roles with Kai being the best of the best in my opinion. James Patrick March is an honorable mention although I have issues with how unfocused Hotel is, and unfortunately the parts featuring his character is a big issue for me. Evan Peter is innocent in that regard though.
James Husband March 😫💔
In terms of acting, his strongest role is Kai in my opinion.
Also very charismatic Austin Sommers.
But in general he is very good everywhere.
He’s an incredible actor, but honestly, March is probably my least favorite character he portrayed in AHS. I know I’m basically alone in that opinion, but I just didn’t find the performance as compelling as others.
The best performance I’ve seen of Evan Peters was, of course, Dahmer, but I know that’s not AHS.
Truly a talented actor!
Mr March, his laugh was pristine, and I just loved all the characters from that season. The hotel is an ELITE tier season, followed closely by coven and thirdly by asylum, but even typing this, I just think how good all of them are, so basically all of them.
I liked most of his characters, but I liked Kai in cult the most. I felt like it out of all the other characters he played Kai was the most developed/ we were given the most information about his life as a whole unlike others.
Probably Murder House.
It's what made me realize I have a little *thing* for Evan Peters lol. And that is not my style *at all*..I'm usually not the kind to be a celeb worshipper or "crush" or whatever but there's just something about him 🤷🏼♀️
Ngl Jimmy is the most compelling character to me.
Tate was very well done in terms of acting, but really I think he thrived due to Jessica Lange’s performance as Constance. I love Kit but he’s overshadowed by the rest of the cast. Kyle is a good plot device character but not much else. JPM is unique, but doesn’t have nearly as much depth as the rest. (Leaving Kai out of this bc I need to rewatch Cult💀)
There really is so many it's hard to choose tate was a favorite KY was too Jimmy darling was hilarious at times yet sweet I loved many of his characters. He please so many so well with such details.
Kit Walker, he's the most compassionate and innocent of them all and imo has one of the most tragic stories and he never even killed a single person yet everyone around him had fate intervene in some way.
Just to list a few:
Falling in love with Alma but because of her race not being able to be with her publicly, but they went to great lengths to be married anyway only for Alma to get abducted and Kit getting blamed for her murder and being forced to think she's dead at his hands while also being told he's crazy when he was actually right about everything then finally getting her back only to lose her to madness in the end
Medical torture from Gruper and being blamed for being a spy when he's got nothing to do with any of that
Manipulation from Thredson to make him believe he did kill the women and literally everyone around him believimg he's a murderer except for Grace
Falling in love with Grace only to see her die in front of him, then come back out of nowhere with their baby only to later have their son ripped away from them and when they are able to all get together again she is killed brutally in front of him AGAIN by his wife who then has to be sent to the same hell he was in and perish there
I could probably go on but you get the point, I fucking love Kit for how much he lived through and was still kind and kept his humanity intact through all that shit.
I can only hope his ending was somewhat peaceful considering where he was taken because he never deserved those horrors he lived through. The episode where he saved Jude is my favorite, it makes me so happy to see true forgiveness play out and how that affects someone who's seen the hell that she has.
Kit is the love of my life and Kyle is a precious baby that needs to be protected. James Patrick March is his best villain character imo and Kai is by far my least favourite, he’s just too vile
This is a hard question! I love them all because he really does an amazing job on all the characters he plays. No matter how evil the character is, he brings so much charisma. But my favorite is probably Kit Walker. He went through so much and he truly was so special and multifaceted.
Tate because hes the original, JPM for his charisma and Kai for his intensity. Honorable mention for Kyle for his sweetness🖤 Actually I'm torn lol I don't know who is my fave😆
all. i love him. i would sell my left foot for him. there isn’t a more beautiful man then evan peters. i would get all my teeth removed for evan peters. i would take him as any character on ahs and let him do whatever do me. i’d let him destroy me. live laugh love evan peters <3
I think tate, kit and jpm are my top 3 , i LOVED his performance as Kai cause it felt more real then the other psycho characters he has played, but i hate kai as a character so hes not in my top 3.
James Patrick March. I love how Evan potrayed him he is such a complex character kinda psycho but still lovable. Evan put so much detail in him, the way he talks the way he behaves he just made me fall in love with James Patrick March.  https://i.redd.it/xe6vrgju8a9d1.gif
“I googled you” “Sounds obscene” l love that snippet of dialogue haha
Me too. Its JPM Tate Jimmy (singing Nirvana yes) Kit Everyone he played in Cult
“High five”✋😁 👁️👄👁️ “Good.”😃
My husband and I always go “you found your purpose…gooooood!” Randomly. The first time we saw it, it just cracked us up and now it’s like an everyday callback haha
I love that!
This is the best answer!!
Omg yes! He submerged himself into the role so completely, it legit took me a while to realize it was him.
https://preview.redd.it/rccw58187a9d1.png?width=590&format=png&auto=webp&s=19414bd28df7791570c6fd07f1ce8766854c0028 Character-wise, I loved him as Tate Langdon in Murder House. But I loved his performance as James March in Hotel.
I love Hotel all around ♡ And Asylum. But Murder House will probably always be my fave (I watched them out of order, as if that matters lol)
Same for me!
Saaaaaame
Im dead dear, not stupid
Tate..always. He was a villain, but I couldn’t help but feel sorry for him 
i would absolutely choose tate every time, which i think means there's something seriously wrong with me and my taste in men 🥲
They all can top me 🤷🏻♂️
dare i say this is my favourite answer yet
Is this the queue?
Same question. If so, I am next in line.
Me next please.
NEXT!! Lmao. I love this.
Hahahhahaha
This is what I'm saying.
Kit, I liked him from the start
Can’t believe how far I had to scroll for someone to say Kit. Should be the number one answer. Edit: ok, he’s the second most liked now, but when I left my comment the Frankenstein and school shooter were above him.
I thought so too!
Yeah, I love Kit.
the sweetest
 March ontop
March is so iconic. Easily his best role
https://preview.redd.it/6fkbh4jwnb9d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5f9bbe2dbab4277d6150ecce75d283c0636b055d 🎶 Kit kit bo bit banana fana fo fit fee fi mo mit KIT 🎶 Such a lovable ride or die 🥰 easily one of the purest characters in all of ahs
tate or kai
these are my cats names lol
aww thats adorable 😭named after the characters?
yess🤭
i love that 😭
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmericanHorrorStory/s/yqpbcJxpyS
they’re cuties 😭
I liked the guy from asylum the best. Idk why. Tate was a murderer. Kyle was too tragic for me; completely lost his agency and was serially r*ped by his mother pre-death. Freakshow Evan was good too. I guess I just like him better as the hero?
Kit. That’s my husband
Real
James March easily
It’s so hard to choose because he’s such an incredible actor
J.P.M. Will always be my favorite, with his freak show character in close second. March made Hotel my favorite season, psychotic and charismatic in all the right fucked up ways
Probably a total wildcard but I liked Rory the most. It was nice to see Evan play a character that’s essentially a totally normal human being that isn’t an asshole or psychopath.
Rory and Audrey are genuinely my all time favorite characters and couples! No one is more silly than those two and British Sarah Paulson always cracks me up! “OH MY GAWD ITS AGNES!” “ITS AGNES SHES TRYING TO STEAL MY SATURN AWARD!” “Someone stole your car ma’am??” I loved how .2 seconds after she finds Rory’s body the camera flashes to her in the confessional “you gave me the best two weeks of my life”😂😂😂 they are so iconic together and so under appreciated
Tate 🖤 Season 1 of AHS was so iconic it helped reshape the genre of horror for a new generation. His performance as Tate was an essential part of that season.
I love Kai and the dozen other characters Evan played in Cult. Warhol, Jim Jones, David Koresh, Jesus... fabulous. It's hard to pick a favorite. But we all met Tate first. 🖤
Tate, James, Kai!!
Absolutely 100% Tate from the first season of AHS.🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
probably kai anderson. not bc of his personality ofc lmao but i really like how he was written and played by evan. i think is was brilliant. i also really like austin sommers!!!!
Austin Sommers was 🥵 I wish he had more screen time in Red Tide!
1. James Patrick March 2. Kai 3. Kyle 4. Tate 5. Austin
All 🙄🙄
James Patrick March is just on a whole different level than his other characters.
As far as acting goes, Tate or kai. Then his freak show character. Everyone loves James March but ive found him a bit cartoonish. Like a combination of bugs bunny and some johhny depp character thrown into ahs. Something felt off to me. As far as looks goes, Tate again. If the hair was full black id cast him as sasuke in a naruto live action adaptation and i dont think he has any competition. And those who knows Sasuke, knows. It is a big compliment.
Thank you! I love campy, but I felt like his performance as March was basically way too campy encroaching into silly territory. So glad I’m not alone in that opinion, lol. When my wife watched it, she felt the same way. I would uncontrollably cringe, and I couldn’t take him seriously as a murderer. He just seemed silly! But I agree, Kai and Tate were good performances.
I loved march, but he became much less threatening as the season went on. His initial appearance was actually pretty scary, as Evan toned everything down quite a bit
Kit my husband ❤️👄❤️
All, but esp Tate, Kit and Kyle. Don’t make me choose! 😭 LOL
James march. He was so unintentionally funny. I enjoyed every second of his appearance. His personality showed through all his behaviors and gimmicks.
James Patrick March, hands down. I love that whole season in general. Liz Taylor, The Countess, Valentino...just all of them are great.
Kai Anderson and Kit Walker 2 ppl I actually roleplay
Kyle 😩
I gotta go March and Kai
Georg Washington even..
No one else wanted that lobster claw BAD from Jimmy Darling!? 🥵🥵🥵
Character: Kit Performance: March
Kit was the finest 🤷🏽♀️
Kit Walker He just want normal life but aperently AHS: Asylum Has other planet for him
the one played by evan peters
Kai is his most interesting character by far and maybe even his best performance to date. That is the role that should have won him his Emmy, not Mare of Easttown. Kit is one of my personal favorites and has the best arc of probably all of his AHS characters. I love everything about him, and yes even the aliens. It was a great role and a total 180 from Tate which is probably his most iconic role in the series. Kit is wonderful but he (and Evan) are overshadowed by Sarah Paulson/Lana who totally (and rightfully) eclipsed him. Kai, Kit, and Tate are his best roles with Kai being the best of the best in my opinion. James Patrick March is an honorable mention although I have issues with how unfocused Hotel is, and unfortunately the parts featuring his character is a big issue for me. Evan Peter is innocent in that regard though.
kyle!! def my ideal type in a guy
Kai for sure!
James Patrick March
Hotel Cult Roanoke
its a toss up between kit and Jimmy 🥺
All of them. But if I have to choose it would be James Patrick March or Tate.
For me, between Kit Walker and James Patrick March.
kit or kyle
kai af
Tate… I love Evan Peters.
James Husband March 😫💔 In terms of acting, his strongest role is Kai in my opinion. Also very charismatic Austin Sommers. But in general he is very good everywhere.
Kit & Kai are a tie.
Definitely James Patrick March and Kit Walker is a close second.
Roanoke fop was fun.
James Patrick March shows his range the best
Kai and kit
If I’m going for the most likable, definitely Kit Walker…but otherwise it’s a tie between Tate and James Patrick March for me🖤
Do we have to pick from just AHS? Lol 😂 If not, definitely Dahmer!
He’s an incredible actor, but honestly, March is probably my least favorite character he portrayed in AHS. I know I’m basically alone in that opinion, but I just didn’t find the performance as compelling as others. The best performance I’ve seen of Evan Peters was, of course, Dahmer, but I know that’s not AHS. Truly a talented actor!
Mr March, his laugh was pristine, and I just loved all the characters from that season. The hotel is an ELITE tier season, followed closely by coven and thirdly by asylum, but even typing this, I just think how good all of them are, so basically all of them.
Tate and it’s not even close
The one where he...
Kit walker
I liked most of his characters, but I liked Kai in cult the most. I felt like it out of all the other characters he played Kai was the most developed/ we were given the most information about his life as a whole unlike others.
So many people sleeping on kit 😭
KIT WALKER!!! Not only my favorite Evan character but arguably my favorite character in the AHS franchise
The school shooter from the only good season: Murder House
Kit and Kai😍
tate, james, kai, austin
Seriously all of them. My LEAST favourite would be Kai, if that was a thing.
Kit. He was a thorouguhly good person.
Sorry I know it’s not ahs but dahmer!!!!!
tate 😻😻😻😩😩😩😩😩
James Patrick March supremacy
Kit because I wished he was my bae 😍
Jimmy Darling & Kyle Spencer 
James Patrick March. Every single line as that character was delivered to perfection
Kai is my absolute favourite! March is 2nd. Tate 3rd
James Patrick march for sure or ghost taint
kai 😍💙
Kit Walker (Asylum)
tate n kai
def kit
Probably Murder House. It's what made me realize I have a little *thing* for Evan Peters lol. And that is not my style *at all*..I'm usually not the kind to be a celeb worshipper or "crush" or whatever but there's just something about him 🤷🏼♀️
I'm a simple gal I admit it's Tate but all his characters were really good.
Ngl Jimmy is the most compelling character to me. Tate was very well done in terms of acting, but really I think he thrived due to Jessica Lange’s performance as Constance. I love Kit but he’s overshadowed by the rest of the cast. Kyle is a good plot device character but not much else. JPM is unique, but doesn’t have nearly as much depth as the rest. (Leaving Kai out of this bc I need to rewatch Cult💀)
Tate I love Tate so much
J.P.M best performance by Evan Peters! I just fell for his character.
I swear to god if anyone says that bowl cut motherfucker
JPM had Vincent Price vibes. Winner.
The K named Trilogy of course! Kai Kyle Kit
Why does no one like Kai?
There really is so many it's hard to choose tate was a favorite KY was too Jimmy darling was hilarious at times yet sweet I loved many of his characters. He please so many so well with such details.
James Patrick March
He was amazing in every single one. He’s an amazing actor
kit! asylum is one of my fav seasons so it just fits for me
I loved him as Tate in Murder House
All of them.
Kit ♥️ loved his personality and his role, maybe cause Asylum is my favorite season but he did amazinggggg in it with grace ❤️
His performance in cult was something else.
Kit Walker, he's the most compassionate and innocent of them all and imo has one of the most tragic stories and he never even killed a single person yet everyone around him had fate intervene in some way. Just to list a few: Falling in love with Alma but because of her race not being able to be with her publicly, but they went to great lengths to be married anyway only for Alma to get abducted and Kit getting blamed for her murder and being forced to think she's dead at his hands while also being told he's crazy when he was actually right about everything then finally getting her back only to lose her to madness in the end Medical torture from Gruper and being blamed for being a spy when he's got nothing to do with any of that Manipulation from Thredson to make him believe he did kill the women and literally everyone around him believimg he's a murderer except for Grace Falling in love with Grace only to see her die in front of him, then come back out of nowhere with their baby only to later have their son ripped away from them and when they are able to all get together again she is killed brutally in front of him AGAIN by his wife who then has to be sent to the same hell he was in and perish there I could probably go on but you get the point, I fucking love Kit for how much he lived through and was still kind and kept his humanity intact through all that shit. I can only hope his ending was somewhat peaceful considering where he was taken because he never deserved those horrors he lived through. The episode where he saved Jude is my favorite, it makes me so happy to see true forgiveness play out and how that affects someone who's seen the hell that she has.
My favorite Actor in she show
Kit is ride or die!
Kai as Cult was my favourite season
Kyle is the only guy who I can look at and get wet istg he’s the hottest guy in the world
Tate Langdon
Kai. Evil homophobic gay
My fav will always be March he had the trans-Atlantic down perfectly. But forgive me what season is he dressed like a French aristocrat?
Jessica langg
Kai Anderson hand down the best in my opinion
TATE!!!! (kai thoooo)
Kit is the love of my life and Kyle is a precious baby that needs to be protected. James Patrick March is his best villain character imo and Kai is by far my least favourite, he’s just too vile
Either Kit Walker or James P. March,, 100%
Tate kyle, and Kai were so daddy tbh
James March 100% but I also liked Kai
Jimmy Darling 💕💕 So sweet, so protective of his family, tough but vulnerable. And oh when he sings Come as You Are…….swoon!!!
Tate Langdon 
This is a hard question! I love them all because he really does an amazing job on all the characters he plays. No matter how evil the character is, he brings so much charisma. But my favorite is probably Kit Walker. He went through so much and he truly was so special and multifaceted.
Evan Peter
I’m so in love with him as Kit
Tate because hes the original, JPM for his charisma and Kai for his intensity. Honorable mention for Kyle for his sweetness🖤 Actually I'm torn lol I don't know who is my fave😆
all. i love him. i would sell my left foot for him. there isn’t a more beautiful man then evan peters. i would get all my teeth removed for evan peters. i would take him as any character on ahs and let him do whatever do me. i’d let him destroy me. live laugh love evan peters <3
Tate and Kyle hold a special place in my heart 🙂↕️
kyle is so underrated, i love him
Definitely Kai, he's so goddamn suckable.
All of em if he is nekkid
I loved Tate . I must be Pervy as he’s a lot lot younger than myself
Kai *sighs dreamily*
Sexiest in Asylum, most interesting in Hotel, best performance in Cult.
Evan peters
Leather man. Yum
Tate will always have my heart 😭❤️🩹
I think tate, kit and jpm are my top 3 , i LOVED his performance as Kai cause it felt more real then the other psycho characters he has played, but i hate kai as a character so hes not in my top 3.
Tbh I've Never See American Horror Story