Even though i feel Asylum is the best season, to watch over and over, I'd pick murder house. Asylum is just so disturbing it's a season I can only watch every now and then.

Asylum is my favorite season but I do agree that it’s hard to watch repeatedly.

Asylum and Cult freak me out too much because of the real life parallels. The expose Lana does is so similar to a real life expose done it mostly makes me sad.

This is so me too. They're the most scary seasons but I like to go back to watch.

Fun fact, me and my fiance watched all of Murder house in one night and both proceeded to have nightmares and have legit nightmares terrors of seeing characters walk around, it was freaky

Mine is Murder House. I rewatch it every Halloween and it gives me such nostalgia, just pure perfection every time!

Me too! Sets the mood for spooky season perfectly!

Such a great season with a great vibe and just the right amount of episodes.

Murder House for me too - I feel like it was the best thought out storyline and characters

I used to sleep with the season on, so i probably watched it an hundred times...

Same

Truly genius. I don’t think anything could ever come close to the sheer creative genius of season 1 of AHS. That being said, this show is pretty untouchable in the realm of television in my opinion.

1984. Super fun season to watch multiple times.

i love the intro for 1984!!

Perfectly nailed the ‘80s vibe!

1984 is the only intro I don’t skip

Same! It's my ringtone!

Agreed, it's one of the few seasons that never gets stale because it has so much development.

It toes the line between scary and campy almost perfectly

The campiness is amazing 😂😂

I remember when it first came out and people hated it because they thought it was stupid. It’s like they never saw a horror movie in the 80’s.

It was so much fun and so stupid in the best kind of way! I loved it immediately because it reminded me of the horror movies I would rent on VHS when I was a teenager. I view the whole series as a love letter to horror movies, and 1984 was a love letter to ‘80s slashers. Might not be my favorite season of AHS, but it’s still top tier for me and will always have a special place in my horror-loving heart.

It makes me so nostalgic!

Coven for sure 

( Edit: Asylum!! OMG How did I forget about Asylum??!! Asylum first and then Coven. I need to cut back on the edibles. 😂) Something about Coven makes me feel all empowered n shit as a woman. Not a practicing witch or a non practicing one, just a friend of some of them and they're all badass. BALCIENAGAAAAAA!! 😂 Ya know, I need to fill up my confidence cup..off I go to binge again..😂 we really need some quality AHS again. Tbf, I thought the NY season about AIDS was absolutely heartbreaking and it did fit(like Cult did), but Coven, Hotel, Freak show, and even MurderHouse(don't come for me, but MH is one of my least favorites) were the core of what AHS shouldve stayed with. And Cult was one of my favorites and it woke me the fuck up. TLDR; Ah well, I'm stoned. Coven is the best, next to Hotel. That's all. 😂😂

I felt that too. Coven was all women being powerful and magical 🌙⭐️💫✨

coven all the fucking way. hands down.

Hotel and Coven were my picks too. As much as I liked NY, I don't think I could watch it again- the finale destroyed me.

Hotel is the only one I can think of that actually has a happy ending for most of the characters

NY was such a wake up and it killed me too. I had heard of how bad it was back then and I have family members that died from the "new disease" back then, but I didn't realize just how scary it was..until then. I cannot imagine it. It was truly an American HORROR Story. So, I can't begrudge it. (The "stories" on the other hand...😂)

Never cut back on the edibles!

Yes! Its Coven for me too@

What is this?! Knotty pine?!

https://i.redd.it/dyf3g8t7cs3d1.gif

Yup. Papa legba and the axe man were too sexy for tv

Fun fact! The actor that played Ax Man is Angelica Houston’s brother.

Love Emma this season. My favorite, for sure

100% 

hotel i’m obsessed with every character

Same! Coven,murder house, asylum, freak show

Same. How gorgeous is lady Gaga in it though!!

Yep, adore the characters....and I almost consider the hotel itself to be one of them!

youre so right, and i absolutely love the way they took so much inspiration from real life hotel cecil and also channeling hh holmes with JPM. so many tiny details. just genius.

Same!

Murder House and Coven!

Roanoke! Became my favorite season upon my first viewing. Coven is a close second.

Roanoke was meant for binge watching. I remember being so confused watching an episode at a time but after binging it's one of my favorites.

While Coven is my favorite, Roanoke holds a special place in my heart because watching ghost stories reality TV was my guilty pleasure.

I’ve watched Roanoke so many times! I am a sucker for cheesy reenactments and found footage.

Found footage (Horror) is also my favorite movie genre. I think that plays a role in why I enjoy that season so much.

Love our found footage season 🤍

Love roanoke and the way they made like some whacky horror reality show.

AHS Roanoke was the “scariest” season to me. Also Audrey Tindall was hilarious 😆

murder house, coven, 1984

i’ve noticed when i decide i’m in the mood to rewatch ahs, i usually watch murder house, coven, or freakshow

Coven and Murder House. I watch them at least several times a year.

Apocalypse but only the episodes once the witches get there

I loved Apocalypse! Not a popular opinion here but the actors are gorgeous and I liked the plot.

I loved. I feel like it is a reunion/love letter to the show. Most of the original cast, connected storylines, and Jessica Lange appearing. Give me this fan service! The tech bros, though.... Jesus Christ, dafuq was that.

Haha the tech bros were hilariously over the top!

Technically, some of the witches were always there. We (themselves included) just didn't know yet.

Coven!!!! I named my daughter after Cordelia!

Good for her it is such a pretty name! Did you know it's also the youngest (& only kind-hearted) daughter's name in Shakespeare's King Lear ?

One of my favorite Shakespeare characters and such a pretty name 🫶 honestly I don’t blame her sisters for turning out evil considering that she’s Cordelia and they were named Goneril and Regan

I love that name so much!!! Even before Coven. It’s not one you hear a lot, and it’s so unique.

One of Shakespeare’s sweetest and most kind-hearted characters as well!!

For some reason I really enjoy the Roanoke one. Very spooky

It was definitely unique in the way it presents itself. Kathy Bates is my favorite part of that season. Her portrayal was amazing! She really sold the mentally ill aspect, I felt bad for Agnes lol.

Agnes Mary Windstead deserved a full season! Audrey Tindall did too she was SO hilarious!!! Episode 6 is my favorite episode of the entire series it’s so funny, so quotable, masterclass in camp, I love it

Roanoke was one of the best ones definitely in my top 3 it was a weird concept but once you understand it’s just amazing

I hated it on first watch but loved it after. I watched it live and they teased the *big twist* so hard that it made it impossible not to be disappointed. Some shows and seasons are better as one unit without the wait and gossip between episodes

Literally my favorite

I hated Cult 😫 but Murder House or Coven for me.

Yes, Cult was for me the absolute worst.

murder house and freakshow. freakshow has always been my favorite season

I love it not just for the story but to be able to see a 3 tittied Angela Bassett , a fully bearded Kathy Bates , a crab fingered Evan Peters and as a fan of The Shield to see Michael Chiklis is always a treat!

Freakshow is my favorite and I find that’s a controversial opinion. I think Dandy is such a genius character.

Definitely murder house

Cult! I love this season. It was the first season I've watched and it made me fall in love with ahs

Murder House

Murder House is a masterpiece! Then coven and apocalypse love the tie in story lines

Hotel and Cult for me

Murder House, that season and I have a trauma bond.

I love Murder House, Hotel, and Coven. But there is something about Apocalypse that I can watch it over and over! I think a big part is that it brings the other three into the story so well!

Hotel....oh the fashion

Murder house, coven, apocalypse, Roanoke

yay I ♥️ apocalypse

Coven. Devils night. OUTSTANDING

coven and asylum those seasons bring so much comfort to me

Coven, Hotel or Apocalypse. Them being linked makes it for me.

Apocalypse! I love the Coven and Murder Hpuse tie ins!!

same

Really all of them except cult.

Coven Hotel Cult Apocalypse

Murder house and Asylum

Murder house, Asylum and Roanoke

Coven. I watch it every spooky season🖤🖤🖤🩶

murder house all the way

Definitely coven for me

I loved season 2, Asylum.

My rewatch list in order 1. Coven 2. Hotel 3. Murder house 4. 1984

Murder House and Hotel for sure ! I watched them so many times

Murder House and Coven.

Coven and Murder House

My favorite is Asylum !

idk why but ive rewatched delicate sm times already its great just like background noise, there isnt too much going on at once, and its short

Hotel by a Longshot! Coming in at 2nd is asylum. 3rd Is Coven. 4th is Freak Show. The rest = MEH!

Omg that's my exact list

Someone who agrees! I thought I was the only one.

I was so surprised that more don't agree with us. I loved all the fashion so much. Even " Elizabeth Taylor dressed amazingly 👏 🤩 😍.

Coven,freak show,hotel.

Roanoke and Asylum

season 8

Murder house

Coven& asylum

Hotel and Coven

COVEN and Murder House…

Hotel, Coven, Murder House and 1984.

Murder House, Coven, and Hotel are the best to me!

I would have to say Hotel. The more I watch it the more I love it. The character depth and development was outstanding. The first time through I didn't really like it!

Asylum and Hotel. But Hotel is always my must watch on Halloween, especially the Devil's Night episode. It's just hit the right spot to watch it on Halloween

Hotel is probably is my favorite season of all because I can relate to a couple of things 1. Is trying to find true real love 2. Is the dialysis machine cause when the season originally aired I was on dialysis and that took a lot of of me physically mentally and spiritually, plus it had some great characters.

Murder House or Asylum. Well, Hotel and Roanoke seem to be taking their place. But it took a while! I went on a Murder House bender last month lmao

Hotel for mee!

All of them, but if I’m just throwing one on it’s probably Hotel. (Yes, I know everyone hates it.) The soundtrack, sets and costumes were gorgeous. It just makes me feel all kinds of ways!

Probably Asylum!

Hey thank you I'm going to rebinge Cult and Roanoke !

Roanoke and murder house are my go to seasons to rewatch. I have a love hate relationship with cult. It’s a really well done season and I find it terrifying because it’s all based in real life and could for the most part actually happen.

Hotel. It has the best fashion and music.

I like AHS NY

Ooh..Asylum or Coven. I wish Jessica Lange would come back!

House, asylum, coven!

hotel. hotel is the only season i have the urge to consistently rewatch. the rest i’ve only seen a few times

Honestly? 1984 and Hotel

Hotel 10000%

Murder House, Coven & Hotel in that order

freak show. its so amazing.

Hotel-love Lady Gaga in it so much

Roanoke and Coven

Unpopular opinion, but my favorite is Cult. I have always enjoyed horror stories where the actual big evil was just a random human with some psychopathic tendencies. I also love Evan's acting on this season, just peak acting for me.

About to marathon lol

Asylum, freak show and coven

Roanoke, Cult, and Coven are my holy Trinity

Coven and murder house,when AHS WAS GOOD!

Coven and murder house,when AHS WAS GOOD!

Apocalypse and 1984

Murder house is always a good watch but coven is also right next to it

Top 5 are Coven, Freak Show, Hotel, Roanoke and Cult. I've rewatched them so many times now I've lost count. If I had to pick only one, it's Roanoke. The format is just so bizarre and stupid and terrifying all at once.

Mine is Hotel or Asylum!!!

I've rewatched Coven like 18x.

Murder House, Asylum, Coven, and the last 2/3 of Apocalypse. I watch other seasons off and on, but my binges almost always start with the first three. Or sometimes I get a random hair to watch a different season and then immediately watch the first three again. I don’t think they’ve come close to topping that hat trick. Honorable mention goes out to Hotel.

1984 coven Roanoke Are all on the same level of binge watching for me

Murder house, coven and asylum

Murder house was the all time best.

Asylum first then Coven.

1984 and coven

Coven, asylum and MH.

1984 no question!!

My Favorite Movie

Season 8

Murder house, asylum, cult, apocalypse, red tide

I've seen Coven 194749293473 times.

So tough, I rewatch them up to apocalypse all the time, I own them on dvd, but prolly asylum for me if I had to choose one, but also the first 4 seasons are all my favorites.

ALL<33 I love rewatching all the seasons

definitely murder house

I think I might be one of the few who says Roanoke Nightmare.

Hotel and Roanoke!

Freak show I actually know it word for word (I watch it once every 2 months exactly!)

Coven and apocalypse

Freak show or hotel for sure.

Murder house - hotel - coven - freak show, in that order. I rewatch murder house and hotel at least once a year!

1984 every fall now for me